FREE EXCEL + PDF

IDP Software Evaluation Criteria: Free Scorecard for Infor & SAP Teams

Provided by DocBits – intelligent document processing for Infor and SAP

To compare intelligent document processing (IDP) software fairly, test every vendor with the same set of your own documents and score them on seven weighted criteria. The most important one is the path into your ERP: whether invoices are matched, coded and posted in Infor or SAP – not just read. Our free scorecard (Excel + 6-page PDF guide) does the weighting for you.

Compare up to four IDP vendors side by side

Weighted totals calculated automatically

Decision summary for your CFO and IT

Etwas ist schiefgelaufen. Bitte prüfen Sie Ihre Angaben und versuchen Sie es erneut.
Fast geschafft – bitte prüfen Sie Ihr Postfach und bestätigen Sie Ihre E-Mail-Adresse. Danach senden wir Ihnen die Vorlage zu.

Kostenlose IDP-Bewertungsvorlage anfordern

Vergleichen Sie bis zu vier IDP-Lösungen mit Ihren eigenen Belegen – mit Excel-Vorlage und 6-seitigem Leitfaden für Geschäftsführung und IT.

What's in the IDP Evaluation Scorecard

The scorecard has two parts: a tool to score vendors and a guide to run the test. It is vendor-neutral – you can use it whether or not DocBits is on your shortlist.

Excel scorecard

Score up to four vendors from 1 to 5 on each criterion. The weighted totals are calculated automatically, and you can adjust the weights to your priorities.

6-page PDF guide

A checklist for your test set, test questions per criterion, questions to ask every vendor, and a one-page decision summary for your CFO and IT.

The 7 criteria for evaluating IDP software

An IDP evaluation scorecard is a weighted matrix that scores intelligent document processing vendors on the same criteria and the same test documents. These are the seven IDP software evaluation criteria in our scorecard, with suggested weights for Infor and SAP teams:

The 7 criteria for evaluating IDP software, with suggested weights
Criterion Weight Example question to test
Path into the ERP (matching, coding, approval, posting) 25 % Test questionDoes the solution post directly into Infor LN, M3, CloudSuite or SAP S/4HANA, or does it only export a file?
Accuracy on your own documents 20 % Test questionWhat field accuracy and touchless rate do you reach with our test set, including scans and long line-item tables?
Security and data residency 15 % Test questionWhere is our data stored, and which certifications (e.g. ISO 27001) cover it?
Human-in-the-loop 10 % Test questionHow does a clerk review and correct a document, and does the system learn from it?
E-invoicing 10 % Test questionAre XRechnung, ZUGFeRD and PEPPOL processed natively, without a separate tool?
Volume and scalability 10 % Test questionHow does processing time and cost change when our volume doubles?
Total cost of ownership 10 % Test questionWhat do licence, implementation and ongoing maintenance cost over three years?

The weights are a starting point. Adjust them in the Excel file to match your priorities – for example, raise e-invoicing if most of your suppliers are in Germany. See how leading IDP tools compare →

Why e-invoicing has its own criterion: In Germany, every company has had to be able to receive e-invoices since 1 January 2025. From 1 January 2027, companies with a prior-year turnover above €800,000 must also issue them, and from 2028 all companies.

Why ERP compatibility matters now: SAP’s mainstream maintenance for ECC ends in 2027, so many SAP teams are moving to S/4HANA. Ask every vendor how their integration carries over the migration.

Field accuracy vs. touchless processing rate

Field accuracy and touchless rate measure different things, and a vendor can score high on one and low on the other. Measure both in your test.

Field accuracy

The share of individual fields (invoice number, date, amount, VAT ID, line items) that the system reads correctly. Shows recognition quality.

Typical mistake in tests: counting only easy header fields, not line items.

Touchless processing rate

The share of whole documents that go from receipt to ERP posting without anyone touching them. Shows how much work your team actually saves.

Typical mistake in tests: testing only clean PDFs, not scans or e-invoices.

A simple example: if 98 of 100 fields on an invoice are correct, field accuracy is high. But if one of the two wrong fields is the total amount, the invoice still needs a manual check – and does not count as touchless.

How to run a fair IDP test in 3 steps

A fair test compares vendors on the same documents, scored the same way.

  1. Build a shortlist of two to four vendors

    More vendors means more demos and less depth per test.

  2. Give every vendor the same test set

    Include the difficult ones: poor scans, handwritten notes, long line-item tables and e-invoices. A demo with the vendor's own samples tells you little about your daily work.

  3. Score, weight and decide together

    Fill in the scorecard after each test, then share the decision summary with your CFO and IT. Involving them early avoids a late veto on security or ERP integration.

FAQ

What criteria should I use to evaluate IDP software?

Use seven criteria: the path into your ERP, accuracy on your own documents, security and data residency, human-in-the-loop, e-invoicing, scalability and total cost of ownership. For Infor and SAP teams, the path into the ERP usually deserves the highest weight, because reading a document is only the first step.

How do I compare IDP vendors fairly?

Test every vendor with the same set of your own documents and score them on the same weighted criteria. Avoid comparing demos built on each vendor's own sample files, because those show best-case results. Still deciding between OCR and IDP? Read our comparison of OCR vs. IDP for ERP users.

How do I test IDP software with my own documents?

Collect 30 to 50 real documents that reflect your daily mix, including poor scans, handwriting, long line-item tables and e-invoices. Ask each vendor to process the same set, then measure field accuracy and touchless rate separately.

What questions should I ask IDP vendors before buying?

Ask how documents reach your ERP (natively, via a connector, or via API/RPA), where data is stored, how corrections are handled, which e-invoice formats are supported, and what the total cost is over three years. The PDF guide in the scorecard lists all questions per criterion.

How does IDP software integrate with Infor or SAP S/4HANA?

It depends on the vendor. Some post documents directly into Infor LN, M3, CloudSuite or SAP S/4HANA, including matching and coding; others only export a file that still has to be imported. DocBits, for example, integrates natively with Infor and SAP. Ask every vendor to show the posting step live in your ERP.

How do I justify an IDP investment to my CFO?

Show the time your team spends on manual entry today, the error rate at month-end close, and the expected touchless rate from your own test. The decision summary in the scorecard puts these points on one page for your CFO and IT.

Get the free scorecard

Ready to build your shortlist? Get the Excel scorecard and the 6-page guide in your inbox.

Something went wrong. Please check your entries and try again.
Almost done – please check your inbox and confirm your email address. We’ll send you the scorecard right after.

Get the free IDP Evaluation Scorecard

Compare up to four IDP platforms on your own documents – with an Excel scorecard and a 6-page guide for your CFO and IT.

About DocBits

DocBits by FELLOWPRO AG is an intelligent document processing platform with native integration into Infor LN, M3, CloudSuite and SAP S/4HANA. It reads invoices, orders, order confirmations and delivery notes with over 96 % recognition accuracy and is ISO 27001 certified. Want to add DocBits to your test? Book a demo and bring your own documents.